ICE is responsible for deporting violent criminals such as the member of the Venezuelan cartel that killed the twenty two year old nursing student
OverstatedSusan Collins, at Maine U.S. Senate General Election Debate 2 (WMTW)
5 hrWhy this verdict View evidenceHide evidence
Why we checked itCollins cites a specific case — a Venezuelan cartel member who killed a 22-year-old nursing student — to justify ICE's role; the details of this case and ICE's involvement are verifiable
What we foundThe core facts are real — a Venezuelan man (Jose Ibarra) killed 22-year-old nursing student Laken Riley and has been linked to Tren de Aragua, and ICE does deport violent criminals — but the claim overstates by calling Tren de Aragua a 'Venezuelan cartel'; it is widely identified as a Venezuelan prison gang or criminal organization, not a cartel, and Jose Ibarra's own TdA membership was reported by DHS sources but not conclusively established in his own criminal proceedings.