Skip to claims
Live now Recorded event · Complete Upcoming

Michigan U.S. Senate General Election Debate 1 (WOOD TV8)

October 8, 2026 · 7:00 PM EDT Methodology v1.7.1 →
AE

Abdul El-Sayed

29 Claims
vs.
MR

Mike Rogers

24 Claims
Speaker
Verdict

Debate hasn't started yet.

Claims and their verdicts will appear here in real time once the debate begins.

—Days
—Hours
—Minutes
—Seconds
Last spoke
Listening. Speaker names appear about a minute after each candidate first speaks.
Live verdicts

Speaker names were identified automatically and checked after the debate. Any correction is noted on the claim.

AE
Abdul El-Sayed 58:57

“Fourteen million dollars. That's what he made when he left congress doing the work for the corporations he had just previously been regulating.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

Rogers's net worth did grow by roughly $12–14 million after leaving Congress through consulting work for technology and cybersecurity companies, but the claim that he made '$14 million' in a discrete payout is not supported by disclosures, and the characterization of the work as serving corporations he 'previously regulated' is only partially accurate — his post-Congress clients were mostly in telecom and cybersecurity, not the broader range of industries he regulated.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 57:43

“He took four thousand dollars alone from DTE.”

NOT VERIFIABLE Click to expand

No available source confirms that DTE Energy's PAC made a $4,000 contribution to Mike Rogers; the specific figure cannot be verified from the records retrieved.

CONFIDENCE 1/3
MR
Mike Rogers 57:07

“he supports the death panels that Canada implemented”

NOT SUPPORTED Click to expand

The claim contains two unsupported components: Canada has not implemented formal 'death panels' as a matter of policy (the term is a contested political label applied to end-of-life mechanisms like MAID and the Ontario Consent and Capacity Board), and no source establishes that El-Sayed has expressed support for any such mechanism.

CONFIDENCE 1/3
MR
Mike Rogers 56:58

“the new cost is twenty thousand dollars per family”

NOT VERIFIABLE Click to expand

The claim that 'the new cost is twenty thousand dollars per family' cannot be verified because no debate transcript is yet available, the subject of the cost (tariffs, healthcare, etc.) is unspecified, and no authoritative source confirms $20,000 as a standard new cost per family for any single identifiable policy change.

CONFIDENCE 1/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 56:19

“While my colleague was in congress for fourteen years, they accrued a twelve trillion dollar deficit. The forty trillion we have, twelve trillion alone, came while he was in congress.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The $40 trillion total debt and Rogers's 14-year tenure are accurate, and the national debt did increase by approximately $12.3 trillion during his 2001–2015 congressional service, but El-Sayed conflates 'deficit' with cumulative debt increase and implies personal attribution to Rogers for debt accrued by entire governments.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 55:45

“We're gonna [raise] four point six trillion dollars by taxing billionaires.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The leading estimate for raising revenue by taxing billionaires under the Sanders-Khanna plan (which El-Sayed backs) is $4.4 trillion, not $4.6 trillion; the $4.6 trillion figure in Sanders's own bill summary refers to how much billionaire wealth grew, not to tax revenue raised.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 54:55

“we cut out eleven billion dollars of a seventy eight billion dollar budget”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The $78.5 billion budget figure is real and matches the Michigan House Republican proposal, but the claimed $11 billion cut is not supported by reporting or official sources, which consistently describe the reduction as roughly $4–6 billion from the prior year's enacted budget.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 53:32

“about four hundred thousand people enjoying those [education savings] plans here in the state today”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The figure of ~400,000 is approximately correct only when all three Michigan 529 plan types are combined, but the largest plan (MESP) alone has roughly 340,000 accounts as of 2026, making the claim an overcount if referring to MESP specifically, and only marginally supportable in aggregate.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 50:39

“Donald Trump has said very clearly that he does not believe that this is sustainable or should be something that we continue to invest [in Social Security].”

OPINION Click to expand

Prediction or editorial opinion.

CONFIDENCE 1/3
MR
Mike Rogers 47:36

“That organization was indicted funneling money to Al Qaeda.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

IARA was indicted and pleaded guilty, but the charges concerned illegally funneling money to Iraq (sanctions violations) and transactions benefiting a Taliban-linked terrorist — not a direct charge of funneling money to Al Qaeda.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 45:29

“When he was in congress, he literally told somebody from the stand, if you don't know your privacy is being violated, is your privacy really being violated?”

SUPPORTED Click to expand

Mike Rogers did make this statement during a House Intelligence Committee hearing in October 2013, confirmed by multiple genuinely independent sources including the original Techdirt report and a first-person account from law professor Stephen Vladeck who was present.

CONFIDENCE 3/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 43:31

“private investors have put two point six million dollars in the [data] center put in your backyard alone”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

Rogers' investments in data center-related companies are confirmed to range between $1.7M and $2.6M, but $2.6M is the upper bound of a disclosure range, not a confirmed fixed figure, and the investments are not specifically in the Saline Township ('backyard') data center.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 43:23

“AI is going to take nearly fifty percent of white collar jobs”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The claim significantly overstates the research consensus: the ~50% figure applies only to entry-level white-collar jobs in one high-profile CEO forecast, not white-collar jobs broadly, and major institutional estimates range from 6–7% to at most ~20% under extreme scenarios.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 42:07

“my opponent here is actually invested into the data centers. He's got a hundred thousand dollars”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

El-Sayed does hold mutual funds with indirect exposure to data center-related companies, but the '$100,000' figure overstates the disclosed range ($50,001–$100,000) and the holdings are diversified mutual funds, not direct data center investments.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 37:47

“he owns two properties, one in United Arab Emirates and one in Egypt”

NOT SUPPORTED Click to expand

El-Sayed's financial disclosures confirm a property in the UAE (Dubai), but his second overseas property is in India, not Egypt — no credible source or official filing identifies an Egypt property.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 36:47

“Twelve trillion dollars the national debt blew up because he's never seen a war he didn't want us fighting.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The national debt has grown substantially and Rogers has consistently supported military interventions, but no authoritative source attributes exactly $12 trillion in debt growth specifically to wars, making the specific figure overstated.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 36:14

“Iran has responded by bombing all kinds of countries in the Middle East and then choking off the world's energy supply.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

Iran has genuinely bombed multiple countries in the Middle East and disrupted global energy supply via the Strait of Hormuz, but the claim overstates the framing: Iran's attacks were retaliatory in character (responding to U.S.-Israeli strikes), and the energy disruption is a consequence of a wider war rather than a deliberate, standalone act of 'choking off' the world's energy supply.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 34:03

“Israel's war aims were the annexation of southern Lebanon.”

NOT SUPPORTED Click to expand

Israel's officially stated war aims were to destroy Hezbollah infrastructure and enable the return of northern Israeli residents — not annexation of southern Lebanon — though a minority of Israeli far-right officials publicly called for annexation.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 33:54

“Israel has pushed us to go to war in Iran.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

Israel — specifically Netanyahu — did push the U.S. toward war with Iran through sustained lobbying, advocacy, and coordination, but multiple credible sources including the Congressional Research Service and Foreign Policy emphasize the Trump administration participated willingly, meaning 'pushed us to go to war' overstates Israel's role as the determining cause.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 29:40

“The IRGC has killed American troops in Iraq.”

SUPPORTED Click to expand

The IRGC has killed American troops in Iraq, confirmed by multiple independent primary sources including the Pentagon, State Department, and detailed incident records.

CONFIDENCE 3/3
MR
Mike Rogers 29:12

“Iran's nuclear program has been set back at least twenty years.”

NOT SUPPORTED Click to expand

Every credible assessment — from the Pentagon, IAEA, DIA, and independent nuclear experts — places the setback to Iran's nuclear program at months to roughly two years, not twenty years.

CONFIDENCE 3/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 27:52

“Donald Trump ripped up the Iran deal in his first term, and then his second term decided to make war that was completely unnecessary”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The factual core of the claim — that Trump withdrew from the Iran deal in his first term and initiated a war with Iran in his second term — is strongly supported by multiple independent sources; however, the characterization of the war as 'completely unnecessary' is a normative judgment that cannot be verified as fact.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 27:40

“diplomacy is what Obama administration had used to negotiate a scenario in Iran where we did not have proliferation of nuclear material”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The Obama administration did use diplomacy to negotiate the JCPOA, which successfully constrained Iran's nuclear material during the deal's active years, but the claim overstates the outcome: the deal imposed time-limited restrictions rather than a durable prevention of proliferation, and Iran resumed and accelerated enrichment after the U.S. withdrawal in 2018.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 26:37

“He has called for open borders, decriminalizing crossing the border, giving illegals identification, and allowing them on Medicare.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

Three of the four sub-claims (decriminalizing crossings, giving identification, and healthcare coverage under Medicare for All) are grounded in El-Sayed's documented positions, but the 'open borders' framing overstates a qualified 2018 statement, and the 'Medicare' specificity conflates his Medicare for All proposal with targeted enrollment of undocumented immigrants.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 25:57

“my opponent voted against border funding when he was in congress”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

Mike Rogers did vote against at least one border-related appropriations bill while in Congress (2014), but the claim that he voted 'against border funding' oversimplifies a record where his objections were typically that bills did not go far enough on enforcement, not that he opposed border security spending in principle.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 24:46

“Ruby Garcia who was killed by an illegal immigrant”

SUPPORTED Click to expand

Ruby Garcia was killed by Brandon Ortiz-Vite, a Mexican national who was in the U.S. illegally at the time of the murder, confirmed by court records, ICE statements, and a subsequent murder conviction.

CONFIDENCE 3/3
MR
Mike Rogers 24:30

“it has been the largest decrease in murders ever recorded, almost twenty percent across the nation”

SUPPORTED Click to expand

The claim that the U.S. has seen the largest decrease in murders ever recorded, at nearly 20 percent, is supported by multiple independent sources covering 2025 data.

CONFIDENCE 3/3
MR
Mike Rogers 22:14

“he said he had ten [years of work experience] on the campaign trail”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

El-Sayed did claim '10 years of public service experience' on the campaign trail, but his two health director roles combined to roughly four years; a figure of ten years requires a much broader and contested definition of 'public service experience.'

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 21:44

“A million dollars alone from big pharma, another million dollars from the health insurance corporations”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The $1 million pharma figure is supported by combining Rogers' campaign and PAC contributions, but the $1 million insurance figure is not supported by available data, which shows substantially less.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 21:01

“He has taken money from groups associated and support the Muslim brotherhood. He has taken money from individuals on his campaign who openly support Hamas, Hezbollah, Al Qaeda. He's taken money from the George Sorrell's family.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The core facts — donations from Muslim Brotherhood-linked individuals and the Soros family — are supported by FEC records, but the claim that donors 'openly support Hamas, Hezbollah, Al Qaeda' overstates the documented connections, and no source identifies an El-Sayed donor who openly supports Al Qaeda.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 20:36

“There are two million Michigan families today who are on Medicare enjoying Part D prescription drugs, which I did champion because there was no prescription drug coverage under a terrible idea.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The claim that 'two million Michigan families' are on Medicare Part D is overstated: enrollment figures consistently show approximately 1.84–1.98 million individual beneficiaries, not families, and the number has only recently approached (but not reached) 2 million.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 20:21

“Fifty billion dollars to rural hospitals was a good start for that.”

SUPPORTED Click to expand

A $50 billion allocation to rural hospitals is confirmed by multiple independent sources, including official government records and independent policy analysis.

CONFIDENCE 3/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 19:25

“He took more money from the pharmaceutical industry than any member of congress, more than any member of congress in the Michigan delegation.”

NOT SUPPORTED Click to expand

No source ranks Mike Rogers as the top pharma-money recipient among all members of Congress; available data identifies other members as higher recipients in comparable periods.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 19:13

“millions of people in this country who fall into medical debt to the tune of two hundred and twenty five billion dollars”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

Millions of Americans do carry medical debt, but the consistently cited total is $220 billion — not $225 billion — making the specific dollar figure slightly exaggerated.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 17:21

“Telefonica is a corporation he advised that was helping Maduro spy on his own people.”

SUPPORTED Click to expand

Both parts of the claim are independently confirmed: Mike Rogers did serve as an advisor to Telefonica, and Telefonica's own transparency report—corroborated by multiple watchdog groups and news outlets—acknowledges it carried out mass surveillance of Venezuelan citizens at the behest of the Maduro regime.

CONFIDENCE 3/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 16:32

“voted to raise your prescription drug prices or to keep them high nineteen times”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

Rogers did vote repeatedly against measures to lower prescription drug prices, but the specific figure of '19 times' originates from votes against children's health insurance (CHIP), not prescription drug prices — independent fact-checkers found at most four to several votes specifically against drug-price-lowering measures.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 16:27

“bought off five million dollars from corporations to run his previous campaigns”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The $5 million corporate PAC figure appears to reflect Rogers' full career total (reported as $5.2 million by Michigan Advance citing FEC records), not money raised for any specific previous campaign or set of campaigns, and some of this total includes the current 2026 cycle.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 15:55

“The Chevy Silverado came back to Michigan because of those tariffs.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The Silverado is being added to Michigan's Orion plant, but the decision was driven primarily by collapsing EV demand, not solely or primarily by tariffs — and Silverado production was already in Michigan before this shift.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 14:59

“The UAW has advocated for smart tariffs where we actually hook it to an industrial policy that makes sense”

SUPPORTED Click to expand

The UAW has consistently and publicly advocated for targeted, strategic tariffs explicitly linked to broader industrial policy goals — including trade deal renegotiation, manufacturing investment, and labor standards — which substantiates the claim.

CONFIDENCE 3/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 14:45

“a Canadian tariff policy that we are paying five thousand hundred dollars a year for”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The ~$5,000–$5,600 figure El-Sayed cites is the total tariff burden paid by Michigan importers divided by household count — not what each Michigan household actually pays — and has been independently rated 'Mostly False' by PolitiFact.

CONFIDENCE 3/3
MR
Mike Rogers 14:08

“His opponent's plan would cost each family about twenty thousand dollars a year in new taxes.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The claim that El-Sayed's plan would cost each family about $20,000 per year in new taxes is overstated: the $20,000 figure appears in CRFB analysis as one specific mandatory-premium financing scenario for generic Medicare for All, not as a net new tax on every family, and El-Sayed has not released a detailed financing plan.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 13:24

“Canada still has some high tariffs for US goods, and they did it before this started.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

Canada does have high over-quota tariff rates on some goods (notably dairy, poultry, and eggs) that predate the current trade dispute, but these tariffs were never actually applied to U.S. goods since quota thresholds were never exceeded, making the claim partially accurate but misleading in its characterization.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 12:02

“Our education is now forty fifth in the country”

PLAUSIBLE Click to expand

Michigan's education ranking of 45th in the country is directly supported by U.S. News & World Report's Best States rankings, though other credible methodologies place the state between 41st and 44th depending on the metrics used.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 11:47

“in the last quarter century, we've lost two hundred thousand manufacturing jobs in Michigan”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

Michigan did lose manufacturing jobs over the last quarter century, but the actual figure of roughly 200,000–244,000+ is larger than the claim implies — '200,000' appears to be a conservative floor, not an exaggeration, making this technically an understatement rather than an overstatement of the scale, though the directional claim is accurate.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 11:35

“Donald Trump called him and asked him to run”

PLAUSIBLE Click to expand

The claim that Trump called Rogers and asked him to run is plausible and consistent with available evidence, but the primary sourcing traces to a single New York Times report citing Rogers's own public remarks and an anonymous source, which have not been independently verified through a separate channel.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 10:43

“If somebody came into his office and he tried to treat that patient, he'd go to jail.”

PLAUSIBLE Click to expand

Michigan law makes practicing medicine without a license a felony punishable by imprisonment, and El-Sayed is confirmed by multiple sources to hold no medical license, meaning the legal jeopardy described is legally grounded — though whether a prosecution would actually be initiated is a legal inference, not a confirmed fact.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 10:14

“He's got a direct line to the president who's making sure the war does not end, and he's not using it because he's true led this war the entire time.”

DISPUTED Click to expand

While Rogers does have a close relationship with Trump and initially supported the Iran war, multiple credible outlets directly contradict El-Sayed's claim that Rogers is 'not using' that line or has uniformly 'led this war the entire time' — Rogers has publicly broken with Trump and called for the war to end quickly.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 9:59

“When you're paying five dollar gas and eight dollar diesel, that's an emergency.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

Current Michigan gas prices (~$4.40/gal regular) and diesel prices (~$6.53/gal) are elevated, but fall meaningfully short of the $5 gas and $8 diesel figures stated in the claim.

CONFIDENCE 3/3
MR
Mike Rogers 9:24

“His [opponent's] policies will cost you twenty thousand dollars for a Medicare for all plan.”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

The $20,000-per-household figure appears in one specific CRFB financing scenario, but it represents only one of several possible financing methods and is not a general per-household cost estimate; other credible analyses put the figure significantly lower.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
MR
Mike Rogers 8:34

“A fifty cents a gallon [gas tax relief measure] went through the democratically controlled state senate [and] they said no.”

NOT SUPPORTED Click to expand

The Democratic-controlled Michigan Senate did not pass a ~50-cents-per-gallon gas tax relief measure — it refused to hold a vote on one at all; the claim has the outcome reversed.

CONFIDENCE 3/3
AE
Abdul El-Sayed 8:01

“the Iranian regime choke holds the Strait of Hormuz making our energy prices higher”

OVERSTATED Click to expand

Iran has significantly disrupted the Strait of Hormuz and driven up energy prices, but the claim that Iran 'choke holds' the strait is overstated given that oil flows have partially rebounded and Iran's control is actively contested by U.S. military operations.

CONFIDENCE 2/3
No claims match the current filters.
Try selecting “All” speakers or verdicts.

What this page shows

Claims made by participants during this event. Each verdict applies to a single claim. The same evidence pipeline is applied regardless of who is speaking.

No aggregate score is computed for the event or for any participant. Per methodology v1.7.1, verdicts are statements about claims, not about people.

Read the full methodology →