“The legislature unanimously overrode the governor's veto.”
The Senate unanimously overrode the governor's veto 24-0, but the House vote was 292-25, making the legislature's overall action not unanimous.
Claims and their verdicts will appear here in real time once the debate begins.
Free account. One email when the debate starts.
Speaker names were identified automatically and checked after the debate. Any correction is noted on the claim.
“The legislature unanimously overrode the governor's veto.”
The Senate unanimously overrode the governor's veto 24-0, but the House vote was 292-25, making the legislature's overall action not unanimous.
“She vetoed the transportation plan. She left a four hundred million dollar hole in it.”
Ayotte did veto New Hampshire's 10-year transportation improvement plan, and the plan was associated with a $400 million funding shortfall, confirmed by multiple independent outlets and the NHDOT itself.
“fifteen percent of the state [are local people hit by the toll increases]”
The 15% figure is consistent with official NH DOT estimates of drivers without an NH E-ZPass, but the claim that all of these are 'local people' affected is an approximation, since residency of non-E-ZPass users is untracked.
“the doubling of the poll tolls which my opponent supported”
The toll doubling is confirmed as law, and Warmington publicly supported it by praising the legislative override that enacted it.
“the three other justices that are sitting on that court right now have sent a joint statement that they participated in the same conduct that resulted in the Chief Justice resignation in scandal”
The three justices did sign a joint statement about the same personnel matter, but it was a collective defense statement found to be inaccurate — not an admission that they 'participated in the same conduct' that caused MacDonald's resignation.
“in the budget that we passed in a tough budget environment, we dramatically increased the amount of money that sent back on special education”
The available evidence contradicts the claim that the NH budget 'dramatically increased' special education funding; state special education aid barely moved between 2021 and 2024, and the state's share of overall special education costs actually declined over that period.
“the Supreme Court has been stacked with political hacks to specifically overturn the education funding decisions”
The claim is an opinion because it attributes a specific motive ('specifically to overturn the education funding decisions') to the judicial appointments, which is an inference about intent that cannot be verified as a factual matter.
“the governor appealed those cases to the supreme court”
The claim that the governor appealed cases to the Supreme Court is confirmed by at least two independent sets of evidence: the Ayotte administration's appeal to the NH Supreme Court in the Rand/Claremont school funding case, and the NH Attorney General's emergency appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court over the student voter ID law.
“Education Freedom Accounts represent less than one percent of four point one billion dollars spent on education”
State officials estimated Education Freedom Account costs at about $51.6 million for 2025-26, after the program was opened to all families, which is about 1.3 percent of $4.1 billion. The share was under 1 percent in 2024-25, when the accounts cost about $27.7 million.
“I vetoed a bill that would have even studied privatizing our public schools”
Ayotte did veto a bill (HB 1358) that would have studied transitioning all public schools to charter schools, but characterizing this as 'privatizing' public schools overstates what the bill proposed, as charter schools remain publicly funded institutions.
“We are nearly last in how much we fund from the state for education.”
New Hampshire ranks dead last (50th of 50 states) in the share of education funding provided by the state, making the claim 'nearly last' accurate — in fact an understatement.
“Only three hundred and forty three of the ten thousand five hundred and ten students who are getting that voucher were in a public school last year.”
The claim is fully supported: the NH Department of Education's own data confirms that 343 of the 10,510 EFA recipients in 2025-26 were enrolled in a public school the prior year.
“we were able to get the cell phones out of the schools”
New Hampshire did enact a statewide bell-to-bell cell phone ban in schools, signed into law by Governor Ayotte in June 2025, which took effect at the start of the 2025–26 school year.
“Governor Jean Shaheen testified before [a body] to basically say, please let us prescribe as much OxyContin as we want”
No evidence exists that Governor Jean Shaheen testified to allow broader OxyContin prescribing; the testimony in question was by Cinde Warmington, a lobbyist at the law firm Shaheen & Gordon, which appears to be the source of the name confusion.
“The FDA was putting out what's called a black box warning before she registered as a lobbyist”
The FDA issued a black box warning for OxyContin in July 2001, and state records confirm Warmington registered as a Purdue Pharma lobbyist in December 2001 — making the black box warning predated her registration by approximately five months.
“She worked as a lobbyist for Purdue Pharma”
Cinde Warmington did work as a registered lobbyist for Purdue Pharma, confirmed by a 2001 New Hampshire state registration document and multiple independent sources.
“She is imposing work requirements on Medicaid. She is imposing premiums on Medicaid and copays on Medicaid.”
Kelly Ayotte did propose and sign into law Medicaid premiums and increased copays, and her signed budget directed the state to pursue Medicaid work requirements through a federal waiver — all three elements of Warmington's claim are confirmed by multiple independent sources.
“People in New Hampshire are traveling across state lines in order to access cannabis products.”
Multiple independent sources confirm that New Hampshire residents regularly travel to neighboring states to purchase cannabis products, because New Hampshire has no legal recreational market.
“Scientific research is showing that recreational marijuana causes an increase in mental illness including schizophrenia and psychosis.”
The scientific evidence shows a strong and growing association between cannabis and psychosis/schizophrenia risk, but the claim that marijuana 'causes' these conditions overstates the current scientific consensus, which has not definitively established direct causation and identifies confounding variables as a key limitation.
“Modern recreational/commercial marijuana is so much higher in strength than marijuana from previous generations, causing addiction especially in young people.”
The claim is well-supported: modern marijuana is demonstrably far more potent than in previous generations, and higher-potency cannabis is independently linked to greater addiction risk, especially among young people.
“Other states are rethinking cannabis legalization — none of that is really backed up, none of it is backed up at all”
The claim that other states rethinking cannabis legalization is 'not backed up at all' is contradicted by substantial evidence: multiple states have active repeal campaigns, legislatures have rolled back voter-approved laws, and a body of peer-reviewed research documents documented negative public health outcomes associated with legalization.
“Kelly Ayotte's irresponsible downshifting of cost to the communities... sent property taxes skyrocketing in our state.”
NH property taxes have risen and some cost-shifting from state to local governments is documented, but the causal chain attributing this specifically and solely to Ayotte's actions is contested, the revenue-sharing reductions predating her tenure by over a decade, and her administration contends it sent record aid to municipalities.
“She opposes a constitutional amendment so we can never have one of those taxes.”
Multiple independent sources confirm that Warmington has opposed or declined to support a constitutional amendment to permanently ban income or sales taxes in New Hampshire.
“She will not commit to banning an income or sales tax.”
Multiple independent sources confirm that while Warmington has said she would veto an income or sales tax, she has declined to commit to a formal legislative or constitutional ban on such taxes.
“Property taxes have been skyrocketing through the roof because of the downshifting and the irresponsible budgeting in Concord that has driven up the cost of everything in our state.”
New Hampshire property taxes are genuinely rising and the downshifting mechanism is well-documented, but the characterization of taxes 'skyrocketing through the roof' overstates the measured rate of increase, and the claim that Concord budgeting 'has driven up the cost of everything' extends beyond what the evidence supports.
“Under Kelly Ayotte and Donald Trump, we have an economy that is difficult for the survival of our businesses.”
The claim that the economy is 'difficult for the survival of our businesses' is a characterisation and value judgment, not a falsifiable factual assertion, even though some underlying economic data points are real and mixed.
“I signed a bill while I was governor so that if we overachieve in terms of our [revenue] — in other words, there's more business tax revenue that comes in, the taxes for businesses will go down further.”
Ayotte did sign HB 155 as governor, and the law does include a revenue-triggered mechanism that automatically lowers the Business Enterprise Tax rate when business tax revenue exceeds projections by $100 million.
“We have the lowest business taxes in the region.”
New Hampshire has the best overall business tax climate in New England, but its corporate income tax rate (7.5%) is not the lowest in the region — Rhode Island's is lower at 7%.
“the governor hasn't appointed a permanent child advocate”
Multiple independent sources, including the governor's own official press release, confirm that as of the debate no permanent child advocate had been appointed, only an acting one for 90 days.
“the Sununu Youth Services Centre has been staffed with law enforcement people”
The Sununu Youth Services Center has been staffed with law enforcement personnel — specifically NH State Police troopers — as confirmed by multiple independent sources reporting from mid-2026.
“the lawyers are taking a third of this [the fund] for doing very little work”
No authoritative source documents lawyers taking one-third of New Hampshire's opioid settlement fund; available primary sources show attorney fees were substantially lower than one-third, with the national settlement framework capping contingent fees at 15% and the J&J settlement reflecting fees of roughly 22% of the gross amount.
“her husband's law firm works for that [the fund/lawyers taking a third]”
Warmington's husband Bill Christie is a partner at Shaheen & Gordon, which actively represents YDC abuse victims through the NH settlement fund, where lawyers can collect up to one-third (33.3%) of client awards.
“the governor has taken away the option to participate in the fund for so many people in our state, forcing them to be retraumatized by trying their cases and enduring a trial”
Governor Ayotte's changes significantly restructured the YDC Settlement Fund — gutting administrator independence and giving the AG veto power over settlements — and her budget initially zeroed out funding, effectively imperiling access for hundreds of claimants; however, the fund was not outright eliminated and victims retain the legal right to remain in or exit the process, making the claim that the governor 'taken away the option to participate' an overstatement of what occurred.
“the governor has thirty five million dollars that she's recently put in here, approaching an election”
Warmington was answering Ayotte, who had just mentioned the money for the YDC settlement fund. The Governor and Executive Council approved $35 million for that fund on October 21, 2026, about a week before the debate.
“Her husband actually worked for a firm that benefits from this financially because they have these cases.”
Warmington's husband, Bill Christie, is a partner at Shaheen & Gordon doing criminal defense work, including representing at least one client implicated in opioid clinic misconduct, which is consistent with Ayotte's claim that the firm financially benefits from such cases.
“We just approved about thirty five million dollars for that fund at the governor and executive council, almost a week ago.”
The NH Governor and Executive Council unanimously approved $35 million for the YDC Settlement Fund on October 21, 2026, approximately one week before the debate in which Ayotte made this claim.
“She defunded the child advocate. She still hasn't got a permanent child Advocate. She has not restored the funding.”
The Office of the Child Advocate's budget and staff were significantly cut and no permanent advocate has been named, but the claim that Ayotte personally 'defunded' the child advocate overstates her direct role — it was the Republican-led Legislature that voted to cut and nearly eliminate the office, while Ayotte's own budget proposal had included funding for the office before she ultimately signed the final budget containing the cuts.
“We learned in March that there were kids, fifteen kids in that facility. She couldn't even keep fifteen kids safe from abuse. The abuse has been for seven months and she still has done nothing to make sure that the kids are safe in this facility.”
The claim that roughly 15 kids were at the facility and that abuse issues were first reported in March is supported by multiple credible sources, but the assertion that 'nothing' was done to make kids safe is directly contradicted by documented government actions, and whether conditions constituted 'abuse' is actively disputed by the NH Attorney General and state health officials.
“Her plan is like California's type plan or Massachusetts type plan”
Ayotte's claim that Warmington's plan resembles a California- or Massachusetts-type plan is a political characterization and rhetorical framing, not a verifiable factual assertion about a specific plan design.
“It's more aggressive than California. It's more aggressive than Massachusetts who has higher rates than us”
Ayotte was describing Warmington's net-zero 2040 energy plan. California's target is net-zero emissions by 2045 and Massachusetts's is 2050, so a 2040 target is earlier than both, as Patch also reported for Massachusetts. EIA data for March 2026 put average residential electricity prices at 30.21 cents per kilowatt-hour in Massachusetts and 26.92 cents in New Hampshire.
“her plan, net zero twenty forty means right now getting rid of the fossil fuels”
Warmington's net-zero 2040 plan does call for a dramatic shift away from fossil fuels, but she explicitly contests that it means eliminating them 'right now' or entirely, and the plan itself does not include an immediate ban on fossil fuels.
“This governor raided the Renewable Energy Fund in our state.”
Multiple independent sources confirm that Gov. Kelly Ayotte signed a budget that redirected approximately $15 million from New Hampshire's Renewable Energy Fund into the general fund, consistent with the claim of a 'raid' on the fund.
“Gas prices are up over four dollars a gallon. Heating oil up over six dollars a gallon. Diesel fuel up over six dollars gallon.”
The claims about gas and diesel prices are accurate, but the claim that heating oil is 'over six dollars a gallon' overstates the current statewide picture, where the median is approximately $5.80 and only a minority of suppliers exceed $6.00.
“Electric rates are up fifteen on her watch.”
ElectricChoice's data put New Hampshire's residential electricity prices up 14.9 percent over the past year, and EIA data reported by Granite Post News show an 11 percent rise during 2025, Ayotte's first year in office. Fifteen percent is the latest year-over-year figure, rounded.
“She offered an energy plan that would bring us to net zero in twenty forty. That's more aggressive than Massachusetts that has higher costs than us.”
Warmington did propose a net-zero-by-2040 energy plan, which is more aggressive than Massachusetts's legally codified 2050 net-zero target, and Massachusetts has consistently higher residential electricity rates than New Hampshire.
“there wasn't gonna be a dump at Forest Lake”
The claim that there 'wasn't gonna be a dump at Forest Lake' is contradicted by extensive documentation showing Casella Waste Systems was actively pursuing permits for a 180-acre commercial landfill adjacent to Forest Lake at the time of the debate.
“There was a bill in the legislature in the last session for a moratorium, and a second bill that would have given local communities the opportunity to have put guardrails around data centers”
Both bills described by Warmington existed in the NH legislature's last (2026) session: HB 1265 proposed a one-year moratorium on data center construction, and SB 439 originated as a bill to give local communities authority to regulate data centers.
“she took money from Purdue Pharma right up till twenty sixteen”
Ayotte did receive Sackler family-linked contributions as late as 2016, but the money came from individual Sackler family members, not directly from Purdue Pharma as a corporation.
“As attorney general, she did not bring the lawsuit against Purdue Pharma that our surrounding neighbors did”
Multiple independent sources confirm that Kelly Ayotte, as New Hampshire attorney general, did not join the 2007 multi-state lawsuit against Purdue Pharma that 26 other states and the District of Columbia brought.
“Cinde Warmington lied to our legislature.”
Whether Warmington 'lied' to the legislature is contested: she did make pro-OxyContin statements before the legislature that aligned with Purdue Pharma's later-proven fraud, but credible sources including a legal ethics expert and a physician who witnessed her testimony dispute that she knowingly made false statements.
“She was a business agent for this notorious pill mill up until twenty twenty four.”
Warmington did serve as a business/registered agent for the PainCare network and its successors, but available evidence places the end of that role no later than 2022 at the latest — not 2024 — with the Warmington campaign asserting it ended in December 2020.
“The work I did was twenty five years ago, legal work on behalf of a client.”
Warmington's work for Purdue Pharma, including her 2002 testimony to the legislature, was about 25 years ago and was legal work for a client. Her legal work for the PainCare clinics, which Ayotte had just raised, continued into the 2010s, so the statement holds for the Purdue work only.
“Then she spends a decade working for a notorious pill mill that was pushing opioids into our community.”
NHPR, the New Hampshire Bulletin, the Union Leader and HuffPost report that Warmington was a lawyer and registered agent for the PainCare clinics for more than a decade. The clinics have been widely described as a pill mill, and a PainCare staffer was convicted of taking kickbacks for prescribing fentanyl. Her role was as the clinics' lawyer, not an employee.
“She testified before our legislature as a lobbyist for Purdue Pharma that OxyContin was a miracle drug with very few side effects.”
Cinde Warmington did testify before the New Hampshire legislature as a registered lobbyist for Purdue Pharma, and she did describe OxyContin as a miracle drug with very few side effects, as confirmed by the official hearing transcript and multiple independent news organizations.
“She was actually the attorney general who did not sue Purdue Pharma”
Kelly Ayotte, as New Hampshire Attorney General in 2007, did not join 26 other states and the District of Columbia in a lawsuit against Purdue Pharma, making the core factual claim accurate.
“She spent her career as an opioid lobbyist. She went before our legislature and lied about being a miracle drug with very few side effects.”
Warmington did lobby for Purdue Pharma and did call OxyContin a miracle drug with very few side effects before the NH legislature in 2002, confirmed by official transcripts and state lobbyist records; but the claim that she 'spent her career' as an opioid lobbyist overstates the duration and scope of that work, which lasted roughly eight months and was part of a broader healthcare law career.
“I got off the board of Bloom in two thousand seventeen. I don't own any of that stock.”
Multiple independent sources, including SEC filings and two separate investigative outlets, confirm Ayotte joined Bloom Energy's board in November 2017 and left in May 2019 — not 2017 as claimed — and her last disclosure showed she held over 4,400 shares, while her current stock ownership is undisclosed.
“She has taken one hundred and thirty eight thousand dollars in campaign contributions from the data center industry.”
Multiple credible outlets consistently report the ~$138,000 figure, but all appear to originate from the Warmington campaign's own accounting rather than an independently verified primary source tabulation.
“She collected stock there that's worth a million dollars.”
Ayotte received Bloom Energy shares worth about $42,000 as a board member from 2017 to 2019, and The Lever and Granite Post report those shares would be worth about $1 million today. She has not disclosed whether she still holds them, and New Hampshire law does not require her to.
“data centers will drive up our energy costs”
Multiple credible outlets and some academic research support the claim that data centers are driving up energy costs, particularly in high-concentration regions, though at least one peer-reviewed working paper finds the national average effect has been modestly negative (i.e., prices fell), making the picture regionally variable and not uniformly true.
“This governor rolled out the red carpet for data centers by signing a bill that allows them to locate essentially anywhere in our state”
Ayotte did sign a bill (HB 672) that made New Hampshire more attractive to data centers by enabling off-grid power, but it is an energy deregulation law, not a siting or zoning law allowing data centers to locate anywhere in the state.
“We put a record investment in our community colleges.”
The NH Fiscal Policy Institute confirmed the SFY 2024-2025 budget provided the highest dollar amount of state support to the Community College System of New Hampshire in its history, consistent with a 'record investment' claim.
“UNH recently announced the New Hampshire promise, so families that make a hundred thousand dollars and less can go tuition free to UNH.”
The New Hampshire Promise is a real, recently announced USNH program that provides tuition-free attendance at UNH and other USNH institutions for eligible NH residents from families earning up to $100,000 per year.
“It is less expensive for Granite State students to go out of state and pay out of state tuition than to pay in state tuition here in New Hampshire”
The core fact is real — NH has among the nation's highest in-state public university tuition, and many specific out-of-state schools do charge less in out-of-state tuition than UNH charges in-state — but the claim as stated is too sweeping, since the majority of out-of-state schools' out-of-state rates still exceed NH in-state rates.
“Thirty two thousand dollars a year for two children in child care on average”
The $32,000 figure for two children in child care in New Hampshire is accurately supported by 2023 data from at least two genuinely independent sources.
“Ninety-five percent of those students stay here in New Hampshire.”
Multiple independent sources consistently find that New Hampshire retains approximately 37–60% of its college graduates, directly contradicting a claimed 95% retention rate.
“Blackstone owns one apartment complex in Nashua and some housing in Durham.”
The Union Leader and reporting on Durham housing confirm that Blackstone owns the Royal Crest Estates complex in Nashua and the Cottages of Durham student housing. The Union Leader also found a Lebanon student-housing property tied to Blackstone through its stake in Greystar, which the claim doesn't mention.
“She gave them no fault eviction, which has caused an increase in rent all across our state.”
The first part of the claim — that Ayotte signed a no-fault eviction law — is well-supported, but the causal assertion that this law has caused rent increases across New Hampshire is not supported by available evidence and is contradicted by current rent data.
Claims made by participants during this event. Each verdict applies to a single claim. The same evidence pipeline is applied regardless of who is speaking.
No aggregate score is computed for the event or for any participant. Per methodology v1.7.1, verdicts are statements about claims, not about people.
One short email every Monday with the debates coming up, the claims with the most evidence, and what the checks corrected.